
On the 1855 map, 86 Clinton St is one of a block of houses on the West Side of Clinton St. near its intersection with Schermerhorn St.. The Smith's home was one of 18 similar lots on the block, shared by a Catholic Church and a private school. The Brooklyn Athenaeum was two blocks south at the corner of Clinton and Atlantic Streets. With a three block radius were a Methodist Church, a Universalist Church, a Presbyterian Church, a Unitarian Church, a Dutch Reformed Church, and a Roman Catholic Church.