By J.B. Priestley
Directed by Dan Wirth
An Inspector Calls -- Director’s Notes:
“Am I my brother’s keeper?” So asks
Cain in the Bible story of Cain and Abel (
Genesis, 4:9.)
How
responsible are any of us for the welfare of others?
Are you responsible for your fellow human
beings?
Priestley’s play asks us to
examine our level or responsibility.
The
play takes the position that society as a whole benefits when its individual members
are cared for.
The current debate on
health care is a good example of this.
Should we all have a hand in a healthcare system that cares for all of
us, or should it be each person for him or herself?
As a trekkie might put it:
Spock: The needs of the
many outweigh the needs of the few.
Kirk: Or the one.
Star Trek II: The
Wrath of Khan
Although Priestley wrote the play
in 1946 (near the end of WWII) he chose to set it in 1912. The Birlings and
Gerald Croft live in a rose colored world, a golden time of prosperity. Many people felt that they were as unsinkable
as the great new British ship the Titanic. The Titanic provides the audience
with a terrific symbol of the hubris of thinking that anything made by man is
perfect, flawless, and incapable of error.
A few short years after the catastrophic demise of that ship, the world
was plunged into a war the likes of which mankind had never seen. The family members deny the consequences of
what is happening in the world and they deny the consequences of the choices
they make in their lives.
The rich and the privileged are
shown to forget that their successes are built on the labor of the people who
work for them. The Patriarch, Mr. Birling,
has been dependent on the people he has perpetually ignored. In the film Citizen Kane (1941) the character Jed Leland says to Kane, “You used to write an awful lot
about the workingman... He's turning into something called organized labor.
You're not going to like that one little bit when you find out it means that
your workingman expects something is his right, not as your gift! Charlie, when
your precious underprivileged really get together, oh boy! That's going to add
up to something bigger than your privileges! Then I don't know what you'll do!
Sail away to a desert island probably and lord it over the monkeys!” As with
Charles Foster Kane, Birling’s denial and self-deceit contribute to a kind of
hubris that has trapped him in a very small world he is desperate to control.
The older generation is seen as
being more set in their ways and the younger generation is seen as more
moveable and flexible. The Inspector tells Mrs. Birling that his work
makes more of an impact on the young. We go on to see how Sheila and Eric are
conscience-struck by their actions while Mr. and Mrs. Birling try to absolve
themselves of blame. The young are flexible
enough to change, the old aren't. This gives the audience hope that future
generations will learn from the mistakes of the past. Priestley sees the hope for the future is
with the young. There were many messages
in the most recent Presidential campaign that echoed this idea.
The play also shows that prejudice
against the less fortunate is not something to be proud of. Mrs. Birling is
infuriated when Eva Smith doesn’t seem to know her “place.” She punishes Eva by denying her request for
aid. Priestley shows us the unfair and
disconfirming nature of such a class system.
So what is to be gained from
Priestley’s cautionary tale? Perhaps we
can be encouraged to look more kindly on the less fortunate. Perhaps we can donate our time in the service
of helping others. Perhaps it does take
a village. Perhaps you will become your
brother’s and sister’s keeper.
"Their hopes and fears, their suffering and chance of happiness, all
(are) intertwined with our lives, with what we think and say and do. We
don't live alone. We are members of one body. We are responsible for
each other."
- Inspector Goole in An Inspector Calls