QUESTIONS TO USE IN DISCUSSING & VIEWING FILMS

 


1. Films can be typed according to genre. In which categories would you put this film?
 

A. Western

B. Mystery / Crime-and-Detective Story

C. Comedy / Romantic Comedy / Sex Comedy

D. Science Fiction

E. Musical

F. Drama / Melodrama

G. Documentary

H. Docudrama

I. Psychological Thriller

J. Horror

K. Fantasy

L. Pornography

M. Social Problem

2. With which character, if any, did you find yourself identifying or feeling empathy for?
 

3. Is this a film that tries to be realistic or to portray fantasies and emotions?
 

4. Which of the following film techniques are emphasized in this film to create a certain attitude or emotion in the viewer?
 

A Camera Techniques
Close-ups
High or low angle shots
Fast or slow panning / Fast or slow motion
Jump cuts
Colors, day vs night, shadows
Distortion, out-of-focus shots / tight focus
Shot/reverse shot
Slow fade
Montage
Parallel action shots
B. Script Techniques
Embodied & disembodied voice-over
Use of written material on screen
Showing inner perceptions & dreams
Use of a single character or object to link story together
Use of narrator
Flashbacks
C. Ancillary Techniques
Type casting
Wardrobe
Music (type, speed, loudness, instrumental vs voice, familiar vs unfamiliar) (when used)


5. Using the list of stereotypes of people with mental illness, which ones are emphasized in this film and what does the film use to create the image? Remember there may be more than one stereotype for a given character and there may be more than one person with mental illness in the film.
 

A. REBELLIOUS FREE SPIRIT - eccentric - nonconformist

B. HOMICIDAL MANIAC

C. ENLIGHTENED MEMBER OF SOCIETY - more sane than "normal" people

D. NARCISSISTIC PARASITE - Self-centered attention seeker

E. ZOO SPECIMEN - so bizarre - cannot identify with them as fellow humans

F. SEDUCER - especially women

G. POSSESSED - under the control of supernatural forces

6. Most often the film turns on the etiology of mental illness. Does this film use any of the following stereotypes in describing
    the "cause" of the current problem?
 

A Trauma in the past

B. Schizophrenogenic parent

C. Inappropriate diagnosis in the past

D.. Inappropriate treatment in the past

E. Poverty / Environmental stress

7. What do the actors say and do to convey the idea of mental illness?
 

8. Does this film present a sympathetic or unsympathetic portrayal of:
 

A Persons with mental illness

B Mental health professionals

C Inpatient & outpatient settings for treatment of mental illness

9. Films often use the Mental Health professional as a plot mechanism. Which of the following ways were used in this film?
 

A. As a ficelle (originally the strings that the puppeteer uses to manipulate the puppet) - to move the plot along
     (cf. the way a one sided telephone conversation can be used)
1. To expound upon & represent one or another ideological stance
2. As the device to uncover dark secrets & hidden motivations
3. To simplify complicated motivations & behavior for the audience
4. To allow for character development
B. As a main character in the plot - either professionally or personally

 
 

10. Mental health professionals are often presented as stereotypical characters. Using the table of stereotypes of the
      Psychiatrist,which ones are emphasized in this film and what does the film use to create the image? Remember
      there may be more than one stereotype for a given character and there may be more than one professional in the film.
 
 

ATTRIBUTE GOOD PSYCHIATRIST  BAD PSYCHIATRIST 
Faceless  Cures by presence  Ineffectual 
Active  Effective / Caring  Manipulative, Criminal or Vindictive 
Oracular  Omniscient: Good Detective Arrogant / Misguided 
Social Agent  Reconciling  Repressive / Malevolent 
Eccentric  Human & Fallible  Neurotic & Ridiculous 
Emotional  Compassionate  Psychotic 
Sexual  Healing lover  Exploitative lecher or Libidinous clown 

 

11. Just as mental health professionals are often one-dimensional characters, so to is mental health treatment.
      Which, if any, of the stereotypical versions of the following treatment forms are used in this film?
 

A. The cathartic cure / Reliving traumatic event

B. Blaming then forgiving parents

C.. Electroconvulsive therapy

D. Psychosurgery

E. Narcosynthesis

F. Hypnosis

G. Hydrotherapy / Lukewarm tubs / Cold Packs

H. Psychotropic Medications

I. Restraints

J. Milieu therapy

K. Commonsense Advice as therapy

L. Behavior Modification Techniques

M. Body Work / Massage / Gestalt Techniques

N. Dream Analysis & Interpretation

12.. Which other films seen so far were similar to this one in their portrayal of:
 

A. Patient stereotypes

B. Stereotypes of Mental Health Professionals

C. Psychotherapy

D. Other treatments

E. Mental Hospitals

13. In what ways was this film different from the others you have seen so far?
 

14. What do you think are the overall effects of this film on the public attitudes toward the mentally ill, mental health treatment,
      and mental health professionals?
 

15. Some therapists use books and films as resources for their patients to help them understand their illness and the therapy
      process or to gain some sense of not being "crazy" or "the only one with this." If you were a therapist, is this a film you
      might think of using? Why or why not?